COLUMBIA, S.C. — Five sitting judges will compete for an open seat on the South Carolina Supreme Court after the legislative panel that screens judicial candidates found each of them qualified and nominated them, the Judicial Merit Selection Commission announced on Nov. 19.
The Supreme Court finalists for Seat 2 are Judge Ralph K. Anderson III of Columbia, Judge John D. Geathers of Georgetown, Judge Eugene Cannon Griffith Jr. of Prosperity, Judge Blake A. Hewitt of Conway and Judge Maite Murphy of North Charleston. On the Court of Appeals, Judge H. Bruce Williams of Columbia advanced for Seat 5 and Judge Aphrodite Konduros of Greenville for Seat 6.
The commission held its public hearings Nov. 16 through 18. Most circuit court candidates cleared, but the panel turned down the entire field for a newly created Seat 3 in the Tenth Judicial Circuit, which covers Anderson and Oconee counties and was assigned to Oconee. All four applicants, from Salem, Tamassee, Seneca and Walhalla, were rated not qualified.
The commission did not publicly explain that decision. During the hearings, panel members asked the candidates about allegations that supporters of one contender had urged lawyers to file negative comments about rivals in the attorney survey that feeds into screening. Every candidate denied taking part, and no evidence of such an effort was presented.
With nobody eligible, the new judgeship, which was supposed to begin July 1, 2027, stays empty for now. A commission staff member said the seat should be reopened for screening in 2027, likely around midsummer. Until then the two counties share two circuit judges.
The panel also found the lone candidate for master-in-equity in Horry County not qualified, while candidates in several other counties were rated qualified.
The record stays open until the commission issues its final report at noon on Feb. 8, 2027, and candidates cannot seek or accept pledges of support before then. The General Assembly is scheduled to elect the judges at noon on March 3, 2027.
Section: More Charleston SC politics news
Filed under: Charleston SC Politics News