COLUMBIA, S.C. — South Carolina’s highest court has sided with the state Department of Revenue in a long-running fight over who owed sales tax on goods sold by outside merchants on Amazon.com, leaving in place a bill of roughly $12.49 million in tax, penalties and interest.
The assessment covers January through March of 2016. During that stretch, Amazon Services LLC collected tax on items it and its affiliates sold, but not on products listed by independent third-party sellers who shipped to South Carolina buyers.
The justices looked at the state Sales and Use Tax Act, section 12-36-910(A), which places a 5% tax on the gross proceeds of anyone doing retail business in the state. The key question was whether Amazon was still in the business of selling items that belonged to outside merchants.
The court said yes. Writing for the majority, Justice John C. Few pointed to how much of each sale ran through Amazon: it governed the product listings, shaped pricing rules, took the customer payments, handled order notices and returns, set limits on how merchants talked with buyers, and paid merchants only after taking its fees.
That level of control, the opinion found, put Amazon well beyond the role of a bank, card processor or advertiser that only supports a transaction from the side. The court also said the statute is clear on its face, so there was no reason to lean on the rule that tax law doubts go to the taxpayer.
Amazon had argued the assessment amounted to applying the state’s 2019 marketplace facilitator law, Act 21, to earlier sales without fair warning. The court rejected that, noting the department assessed the company under the law as written in 2016.
One justice dissented, reasoning that Amazon could fairly claim its fees were for services rather than for the goods themselves, and that such doubt should favor the taxpayer.
The case began at the Administrative Law Court, and the state Court of Appeals had already ruled for the department before the Supreme Court took it up. Today, marketplace operators selling into South Carolina collect and remit tax on third-party sales under the 2019 law.
From the HERE City State Desk
Section: More Charleston SC business news
Charleston business profiles
Filed under: Charleston SC Business News