Former Lawyer Indicted in Cold Case Murder of Aliza Sherman

News Summary

Gregory J. Moore, a former divorce attorney, has been indicted for the murder of Aliza Sherman, who was brutally stabbed in 2013. The indictment reveals a chilling plot connected to her divorce trial. After fleeing to Texas, Moore was apprehended by U.S. Marshals. Legal experts expect a significant trial ahead as he faces multiple serious charges, including aggravated murder and conspiracy.

Former Divorce Attorney Indicted for Long-Unsoved Murder

In a stunning twist in a case that has gripped Cleveland for over a decade, former attorney Gregory J. Moore, 51, has been secretly indicted for the shocking murder of Aliza Sherman. The indictment, which came down on May 2, 2025, alleges that Moore was complicit in a heinous plot that culminated in the stabbing death of Sherman outside his own law office on March 24, 2013.

A Troubling Past

Moore, who obtained his law license in 2003 after studying at Cleveland State University, had a tumultuous career marked not only by his practice at Stafford Law Company from 2011 to 2014 but also by a checkered criminal record that dates back to 1998. Initially, his run-ins with the law were minor, comprised mostly of traffic offenses. However, the situation escalated in 2013 when he made headlines after being charged with multiple counts of inducing panic for phoning in bomb threats to evade court appearances.

Ultimately, he faced a plea deal in May 2017 that saw him admit to two counts of felony inducing panic and one count of falsification for lying to the FBI regarding his whereabouts during the time of Sherman’s murder. Moore served six months in jail as a result of these charges. Following this, his legal license was suspended in 2017, and he officially resigned in 2018 while a disciplinary action was pending against him.

The Gruesome Murder

Aliza Sherman was tragically found with multiple stab wounds just steps away from Stafford Law Company on that fateful night in 2013. Despite the swift action of authorities, she succumbed to her injuries shortly after arrival at MetroHealth Medical Center. The events leading up to her death now reveal a disturbing pattern of premeditated intent. According to the indictment, Moore is alleged to have orchestrated a plot to kidnap Sherman, cleverly timed to coincide with her divorce trial scheduled for March 25, 2013.

In an even more chilling turn of events, after the brutal attack, Moore reportedly attempted to mislead investigators by sending text messages to Sherman, fully aware that she was incapacitated and unable to respond. This calculated move only adds to the eerie nature of the allegations against him.

Decade-Long Wait for Justice

For over ten years, the murder of Aliza Sherman posed a significant challenge for law enforcement. Despite the ordeal, the case remained unresolved until recent developments led to the indictment of Moore. When Moore fled to Austin, Texas, authorities eventually apprehended him with the help of U.S. Marshals following the indictment.

Now, Moore faces a litany of serious charges, including aggravated murder, conspiracy, six counts of murder, and two counts of kidnapping. This myriad of severe allegations reflects the egregiousness of the crimes he is accused of committing. Legal experts anticipate that his arraignment will take place in Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court in the near future.

Personal Connections to the Case

Compounding the tragic elements of this case, Aliza Sherman’s estranged husband, Dr. Sanford Sherman, has since passed away and was never deemed a person of interest during the investigation. The unfortunate intertwining of personal and legal battles only serves to amplify the haunting narrative surrounding this long-cold case.

As this story unfolds, all eyes will be on the courtroom proceedings, eager to see if Gregory J. Moore will finally face justice for the alleged brutal murder that has haunted many for far too long.