---
title: "Columbia Pushes Back on Demand to Fire Its Fire Chief"
url: https://www.herecharleston.com/2026/11/21/columbia-rejects-irmo-fire-demand-fire-chief-jenkins-lawsuit/
date: 2026-11-21T10:05:03-05:00
modified: 2026-11-21T11:18:51-05:00
author: "Amparo R. Hurtado"
categories: ["Politics"]
site: "HERE Charleston"
attribution: "HERE Charleston"
---

# Columbia Pushes Back on Demand to Fire Its Fire Chief

> COLUMBIA, S.C. — The City of Columbia, South Carolina, is publicly rejecting a settlement proposal that would require it to remove its fire chief and a top deputy, calling the demand egregious in a statement posted to social media on the night of Thursday, Nov. 19. The proposal came from the Irmo Fire District, which

*Source: [HERE Charleston](https://www.herecharleston.com/2026/11/21/columbia-rejects-irmo-fire-demand-fire-chief-jenkins-lawsuit/) — November 21, 2026 by Amparo R. Hurtado*

COLUMBIA, S.C. — The City of Columbia, South Carolina, is publicly rejecting a settlement proposal that would require it to remove its fire chief and a top deputy, calling the demand egregious in a statement posted to social media on the night of Thursday, Nov. 19.

The proposal came from the Irmo Fire District, which the city pulled into a wrongful-death lawsuit over the loss of James Michael Muller, an Irmo firefighter. Muller, 25, was killed on May 26, 2023, when a burning building at the Tropical Ridge Apartments in Columbia gave way.

In an offer of judgment filed this week in Richland County, lawyers for the fire district said they would end the dispute with the city if Columbia-Richland Fire Department Chief Aubrey Jenkins and Assistant Chief of Operations Anthony Holloway are fired and both men issue written public apologies. The offer also asks the city to pay roughly $40,296 to cover legal bills for the district and to agree to the dismissal of every claim against the district.

According to the filing, making the offer does not mean the district admits fault, and the city has 20 days to accept.

In its post, the city said it does not comment on pending litigation, disagrees with the allegations raised by opposing lawyers and expects to defend the department’s firefighters in front of a neutral jury.

The underlying lawsuit was filed by Muller’s widow, Emma Muller, against the city and Richland County. It argues that heavy water streams aimed at the roof of an already weakened building helped bring it down, and that confusion at the scene left Muller trapped for at least 45 minutes. The city then brought a third-party claim arguing that the Irmo Fire District should share any liability.

A 2025 line-of-duty death report from NIOSH, the federal agency that studies workplace safety, pointed to communication breakdowns, gaps in tracking crews at the scene and a weak grasp of the building’s structural condition. The collapse also trapped three other Irmo firefighters, all of whom made it out alive.

Depositions are now underway, and the case could reach trial by spring, with Fifth Circuit Judge Daniel Coble presiding.
